You’re being redirected to the application you selected.

Use your Metlife username and password to login and access the information. If you have trouble loggin in, please call us at (800) 504-0739.

Discuss How RILAs Can Help Reduce Overall Portfolio Costs

Explaining how a RILA can be offered without base product fees can help reinforce your position as a transparent and trusted partner.

This content is intended for Financial Professional use only. If you are not a Financial Professional, please visit the Brighthouse Financial public site here.

Questions This Article Can Help You Answer

 

  • How can insurance companies offer registered index-linked annuities (RILAs) without base product fees?
  • What fees are associated with RILAs?
  • How are RILA fees different than traditional variable annuity (VA) fees?

The term “fee” often has a negative connotation for clients, so being transparent about annuity fees is important for building trust. Certain annuity products include annual charges – either as flat fees or percentage of value – related to actions such as withdrawing money from the investment. Registered index-linked annuities (RILAs) don’t typically have any base product fees, so adding a RILA to a client’s portfolio could help reduce the portfolio’s overall fee percentage, which may be appealing to clients.

One of the most often cited reasons some consumers dislike annuities is because of the associated annuity fees.1 Traditional variable annuities (VAs) can be subject to an administrative fee and investment ratio expenses. One of the benefits of RILAs (also known as buffered annuities) is that they could reduce or potentially eliminate annual fees by tracking the performance of one or more indices rather than investing directly in an index. Explaining how fees work in different types of annuities may help clients feel more confident about considering a RILA as part of their portfolio. Sales of RILAs increased from $38.7 billion in 2021 to $47.4 billion in 2023. During that time, VA sales declined from $86.6 billion to $51.4 billion in 2022.2

RILA Sales Are on the Rise

RILA sales have been on a steady rise since 2018.

“Fees are a hot-button topic, and investors are clamoring for transparency and for simplicity,” notes Chris Bunting, Vice President, Divisional Sales Manager, and Advisor to Product Development at Brighthouse Financial.“ The RILA conversation allows a financial professional to engage in a very holistic way to talk about the impact of fees on a portfolio over the long term.”

Understanding RILA Fees

One important feature of RILAs (buffered annuities) to share with clients is that they don’t typically have any base product fees. Even when annual fees are moderate, a client may still have concerns that all of their money isn’t working on their behalf. If clients have previously invested in financial products that have annual fees or expenses, a product without annual fees might be a change for them – and one that could encourage interest in RILAs.

Variable annuities usually have fees or charges associated with their administration, mortality expenses, riders, and – because VAs invest directly in subaccounts – investment expense ratios. One of the significant differences with a RILA is that it tracks the performance of one or more indices rather than investing directly in an index, so investment expense fees do not apply.

“We know that clients work very hard for their money, which means they want their money to work equally hard for them,” says Meghan Doscher, Senior Vice President and Chief Marketing Officer at Brighthouse Financial. “Because a RILA generally has no annual or base fees, RILA contract owners can see that more of their money is invested in their future rather than covering expenses that other products may charge.”

Although many RILAs (buffered annuities) feature no base product fees, other costs may be associated with the purchase, so it’s important for financial professionals to be transparent with clients about those instances when fees or charges may occur. For example, a fee or charge may apply if the client withdraws more than the amount allowed by the contract before the end of the surrender period. In one survey, 21% of people said a better explanation of fees from their financial professional may have convinced them to purchase an annuity.3

Helping Clients Visualize the Impact of Fees

Discussing fees with clients is important because it’s often one of the more challenging things for clients to understand. One way to demonstrate how fees can affect a client’s investment, especially when comparing multiple financial products, is to show the impact of fees over the long term.

The Impact of Fees on an Investment

Account value of a $100,000 investment after 30 years, assuming 6% annual growth.

Staying Fully Invested in the Market vs. Missing Its Best Days

Source: NerdWallet Mutual Fund Calculator.

“Typically, a RILA has no annual fees, so it can help with the cost of the overall portfolio,” advises Leslie Williamson, Head of Digital Distribution at Brighthouse Financial. “If a client needs additional features, then they can add those and only pay for what they need, like a living benefit rider.”

How Do RILAs Operate Without an Annual Fee?

For clients familiar with the fee structure of other types of investments, the concept of a product like a RILA (buffered annuity) without base product fees may seem too good to be true. Financial professionals can consider explaining how insurance companies are able to offer a RILA without base product fees.

One way to help clarify this is to share that the annuity purchase payment isn’t invested in an index fund, so that eliminates the expense ratio usually associated with mutual funds or exchange-traded funds (ETFs). Instead, the annuity tracks the performance of an index and credits the investor with the change in the index, taking into account the selected crediting strategy and buffer.

With a portion of the premium, the insurance company purchases options to cover growth in the index and purchases other options to provide a level of downside protection if the market declines. It also invests a portion of the purchase payment in high-quality assets.

“More specifically, what insurance companies are doing is purchasing an at-the-money call, which provides for the upside potential; selling an out-of-the-money call, which provides for a cap; and then selling an out-of-the-money put, which is what offers the guaranteed downside level of protection,” Chris explains. “And the remainder of the dollars are typically invested in a basket of very high-quality, fixed-income securities.”

Explaining the Difference Between Fees and Potential Costs

While a RILA (buffered annuity) doesn’t typically have any base product fees, financial professionals should consider discussing the potential costs of an annuity with clients. This conversation could be approached by discussing what features or functionality an investor may be exchanging to have the benefits of a RILA – the opportunity for market gains with a level of downside protection. Chris puts these costs into four categories:

  • Liquidity cost: The investor may be entering a contract that has a surrender schedule, meaning they may not have access to their entire account value without a charge or fee.
  • Opportunity cost: For RILAs that come with a Cap Rate (also known as a ceiling), an investor could be giving up the opportunity to earn more if their investments perform above the Cap Rate. For RILAs using the Step Rate crediting strategy, which credits a predetermined percentage of growth if index performance is flat or up at the end of the term, the investor’s rate of return may be less than the change in the index value.
  • Dividend cost: RILAs don’t directly invest in an index, so there are no dividends like an investor may receive with mutual funds or other types of investments.
  • Flexibility cost: There aren’t many ways a client can change their index option once the term has started, and they may only have a few indices to choose from in a RILA.

“I think it’s critical to be up front about the realities of this type of an investment,” Chris says. “That can help reduce skepticism.”

By having these discussions early in the planning process, financial professionals can help educate clients about what a RILA offers compared to other investments. Being transparent about benefits, fees, and costs can help build trust with clients who may have misconceptions about annuities.

1 Annuities’ Bad Rap. PLANADVISER, September 27, 2022.

2 LIMRA: U.S. Annuity Sales Post Another Record Year in 2023. LIMRA, January 24, 2024.

3 Income tops annuity buyers’ reasons for purchase, study says. InsuranceNewsNet, May 24, 2023.

Withdrawals of taxable amounts are subject to ordinary income tax. Withdrawals made before age 59½ may also be subject to a 10% federal income tax penalty. Distributions of taxable amounts from a non-qualified annuity may also be subject to the 3.8% Net Investment Income Tax that is generally imposed on interest, dividends, and annuity income if the modified adjusted gross income exceeds the applicable threshold amount. Withdrawals will reduce the death benefit and account value. Withdrawals may be subject to withdrawal charges.

Annuities are issued by, and product guarantees are solely the responsibility of, Brighthouse Life Insurance Company, Charlotte, NC 28277 and, in New York only, by Brighthouse Life Insurance Company of NY, New York, NY 10017 (“Brighthouse Financial”). Variable products are distributed by Brighthouse Securities, LLC (member FINRA). All are Brighthouse Financial affiliated companies. Annuities are long-term investments designed for retirement purposes. The contract prospectuses and contracts contain information about each contract’s features, risks, charges, expenses, exclusions, limitations, termination provisions, and terms for keeping the contract in force. Prospectuses and complete details about each contract are available from a financial professional and should be read carefully. Product availability and features may vary by state or firm.